Tom Wark has been forced to change the name of his excellent wine industry blog from FERMENTATIONS to FERMENTATION (or perhaps Fermentation - Tom?).
Since it involves lawyers and Tom isn't talking, I can only presume that someone got upset and hired a lawyer (disclaimer: this is just my supposition). I notice a plethora of TMs on that "other" site, which (a) look like crap (use the ™ HTML encoding instead), and (b) demonstrate ignorance (only the first appearance of a trademarked name on a page requires the ™ or ® symbol).
If you are a reader of Tom's blog, please make note of the change, update your bookmarks, change your RSS subscriptions, etc. to refer to
And if you're not already a regular reader, you should be. Tom is a pleasure to read, regardless of whether you agree with everything he says.
Pass the word along. And just generally, isn't there a better solution than calling in the lawyers? Why not a free ad for your business on Tom's blog? I bet he's getting more traffic that you are (whoever you are). Yes, I know that legally you need to protect a trademark, but this seems a triumph of legality over common sense.
Thanks for the kind words, Mike. I can't let it go without saying your support is really appreciated!
cheers,
Tom....
Posted by: Tom Wark | November 01, 2005 at 11:13 AM
Well, I just think it's silly. Makes me want to smack a lawyer or something. So, in lieu of that, I wrote this post.
Posted by: Mike Duffy | November 01, 2005 at 11:23 AM
While tom is a sterling guy and you rightly lament the turn of events, as a advisor to wineries shouldn't you use this situation as a cautionary tale rather than just a gripe session. Wineries should always check for possible overlap. I think it is understandable that Fermentations, the store, wanted Mr. Wark to cease and desist. Another example: one group of wineries in Napa Valley, in forming a coop marketing enterprise, considered then discarded using ~artisan~ in the name since Jess Jackson has, properly or improperly made this generic term a proprietary term for one of his divisions.
Posted by: tom merle | November 20, 2005 at 07:47 PM